Here is where I will keep track of the flicks I've watched. If you see typos or errors, or you really like what I wrote, or maybe you flat out disagree with me. Don't be shy! Lemme know what YOU think.
I almost stopped watching this because I couldn't make out the Scottish accents. I kinda wish I'd stopped because it's a dumb story. It's got a nice message and all, with the mom wanting to protect her son, but bleagh, it's so sentimental and doesn't make much sense, at least in a plausible way. It's pretty romantic and has a fairly happy ending, but there were way too many moments where I was scratching my head with, yeah that would happen kinda thoughts. I think it's supposed to be set in the past when cell phones and the internet didn't exist, because the movie would be even less plausible if people didn't have to rely on newspaper ads to communicate. On a story level I could see it satisfying a lot of people, but it wasn't my cup of tea - too sappy. I did like the actors, (Gerard Butler oooo!), but they aren't working with the greatest material.
Also, the fact that the boy was deaf, seemed like a stunt, and I didn't think his deafness was portrayed with realism. The domestic violence issues were more integrated with the story though. It wasn't a terrible film. I think a lot of people will enjoy it, probably Scottish folk, and if you're a fan of Gerard Butler helps, because he's in a lot of scenes. :)
I didn't even know there was a play called Coriolanus. Shakespeare no less. It set me up the bomb, thinking dayum, why ain't this ever been made into a movie? Is it Shakespeare's shittiest work or what? What's the story mang?
Well, I dunno why this isn't more popular, probably because it's too bloodthirsty. Joe was hating on it, feeling bored and eye rolly of it. We got into a heated discussion about how believable or translatable it is to modern times.
It's done up with modern trappings. No Togas, or laurel wreaths. Instead of Roman garb, soldier/general Coriolanus wears a conventional uniform, a dressier one when he's getting his accolades with the politicians and in green battle fatigues when he's in the field killing the enemy like the super soldier he is.
That's another aspect that bugged Joe. The whole idea of a super soldier.
I felt like it was condemning of a militaristic ideology, while he more felt it promoted and glorified one, because it neglected to include other more important factors like who controls the military. Rogue generals are fewer and farther between in the modern era. I still feel it was more a story of the individual - another thing that bugged him. The emphasis on individual actions.
But the personal is political. Coriolanus's mom, (Vanessa Redgrave), bred herself a super soldier, and he bred himself a son who was gonna be a super soldier too. The context of the conflict was less important than the essential nature of the conflict, that of one nation or state, subjugating another. And what does a warrior culture do but justify the need for a warrior class by making sure that war continues. Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia. This cynical tale shines a light some on the machinations behind the scenes that makes sure the ballet of blood and bullets is a neverending story, and that might be disheartening, but it's honest. It's human weakness and moral flaws that exacerbate conflict.
I like watching Shakespeare. I like how I have to pay attention to what's going on and try figure out what was said. I spend much of the time watching in a state of huh? Whatssat? Ohhhh ok, and I don't get that much from most any other kind of flick. Most flicks are OBVIOUS. Everything is telegraphed and that can be BORING. Shakespeare makes you work a bit for your entertainment.
It's got some damn fine scenes of the sexy mens too. Probably the most war mongery homoerotic flick I've seen since 300, and that starred Gerard Butler too. Though there might be others that are more sexier, just that I ain't seen them. I'm not often watching war oriented flicks generally, but I hear they're popular with the macho set. I'm thinking this might fly with all the dudes what like FPS war games since the action scenes are modern warfare. Could be a cross promotional venture - Coriolanus coming soon to a console system near you!!
